top of page

The Mother You Thought You'd Be: The Identity Shift of Early Motherhood

Tristin Arcouette
Jul 17
4 min read

Updated: 2 days ago


No one hands you a map for who you become after having a baby. There was a picture of the mother you'd be, patient, present, put-together, and most days the reality feels like a stranger wearing your clothes. The exhaustion is expected. The grief for the person you used to be, the friendships that quietly faded, the work identity that feels distant, that part tends to catch women off guard.


Matrescence, the psychological transition into motherhood, gets almost none of the airtime adolescence gets, even though it reshapes identity just as thoroughly. Hormones shift, sleep disappears, relationships renegotiate themselves, and somewhere in the middle of it a woman is expected to keep functioning, often without much acknowledgment that anything has changed at all.


It's common to feel two things at once: fierce love for a child and quiet mourning for a life that no longer exists in the same shape. Neither cancels the other out. Guilt tends to show up here, guilt for missing the old life, guilt for not feeling constantly grateful, guilt for needing a break. That guilt usually isn't a sign something is wrong. It's a sign the identity shift hasn't been given anywhere to land.


Therapy for this transition isn't about deciding whether motherhood was the right choice. It's about making room for all of it: the love, the loss, the resentment that surfaces sometimes, the parts of an old identity worth carrying forward, and the parts that can be let go of on purpose rather than by default. Sessions draw on Internal Family Systems (IFS) to work with the different parts holding these conflicting feelings, and Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) to help partners understand each other through a transition that changes both people.


This isn't a phase to just push through alone. Real support is available in person in NW Calgary or online across Alberta, with a free 15-minute consultation as a low-pressure starting point.

Matrescence is a real transition, not a mood

The word matrescence was coined by anthropologist Dana Raphael in the 1970s and brought back into use by psychiatrist Alexandra Sacks, who describes it as the developmental passage into motherhood, as physical, hormonal and psychological as adolescence. Framing it that way matters. If becoming a mother is a transition rather than a state you arrive at, then feeling unsettled, ambivalent or unlike yourself in the first year or two is the ordinary shape of the passage, not evidence that something is wrong with you.

When it is more than adjustment

Statistics Canada's 2019 Survey on Maternal Health found that almost one in four mothers who had recently given birth reported feelings consistent with postpartum depression or an anxiety disorder, and most of them had not planned for it. Ordinary matrescence and a perinatal mood or anxiety disorder can look alike from the inside, so it helps to know the differences. Adjustment tends to come and go, lifts with sleep and support, and still leaves room for moments of pleasure. Depression or anxiety is more constant, lasts beyond two weeks, interferes with eating, sleeping when the baby sleeps, or caring for yourself, and often brings a flat, hopeless or frightened quality that does not shift. Intrusive thoughts about harm coming to the baby are common and distressing; they are a symptom of anxiety, not a statement about who you are, and they are something therapy can work with directly.

Your public health nurse or family doctor can screen you with the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale, which takes a few minutes. Alberta Health Services offers this routinely, and you can ask for it at any visit, not only the first one.

What therapy for this transition actually involves

Sessions start with the version of you that is here now, not the one you expected. We look at what has been lost, what has been gained, and the parts of you that are in conflict about it: the part that wanted this, the part that misses the old life, the part that is furious at how unequal the load feels, the part that keeps saying you should be grateful. Internal Family Systems gives those parts room to speak without any one of them being the whole story. Where a partner is involved, Emotionally Focused Therapy helps both of you understand the other person's experience of a change that happened to both of you, which tends to lower the resentment faster than negotiating chore charts.

Practical work sits alongside it: sleep protection, naming the mental load out loud, deciding what help you will accept and from whom, and planning for the return to work or the choice not to return, which carries its own grief.

Perinatal support in Calgary

Beyond therapy, Alberta's Health Link (811) can connect you with public health nursing, and your family doctor can assess whether medication is worth considering alongside counselling; it is a joint decision and many mothers do both. If you are pregnant or thinking about a pregnancy, the same support applies: perinatal mental health includes the months before birth and after a loss, not only the postpartum period.

Working on this at Truepath

Truepath Women's Therapy is the women's practice of Pathfinder Therapy, in Kensington, NW Calgary, with online sessions across Alberta. Sessions are with Nancy Jassi, MACP, CCC, a Canadian Certified Counsellor who also offers counselling in Punjabi and Hindi. A 50-minute session is $190, direct billing may be available with many extended health plans, and the first step is a free 15-minute consultation where you can ask anything before deciding. Book a free consult or read more about perinatal and maternal mental health counselling.

If you are in crisis or thinking about harming yourself, call or text 988 (Canada's suicide crisis helpline), call Alberta's Mental Health Help Line at 1-877-303-2642, or call 911.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page